How to Spot AI-Written Essays (And Why Some Professors Still Can’t)

With AI-powered tools like ChatGPT, students can generate essays in seconds. While this technology can be a great study aid, it also raises concerns about academic integrity. Many professors struggle to tell the difference between human-written and AI-generated content, making it easier for some students to submit AI-created work without detection.

However, AI writing still has telltale signs. Whether you’re a student curious about AI limitations or a professor trying to maintain academic honesty, knowing how to identify AI-generated essays is valuable. Some assignments, like a reflection paper, require personal insight and analysis that AI often struggles to replicate authentically. This makes spotting AI-written work easier in some cases but far more challenging in others.

So, why do some professors still miss AI-generated essays? And how can you spot them? Let’s break it down.

Why AI-Written Essays Can Be Hard to Detect

AI-generated writing is improving rapidly. Unlike early AI tools that produced robotic, unnatural text, today’s AI can mimic human writing styles fairly well. Here’s why some professors struggle to catch it:

  • AI Can Mimic Sentence Structure – Many AI tools generate well-organized, grammatically correct sentences, making them look polished at first glance.
  • It Avoids Simple Plagiarism Detectors – AI doesn’t copy content from a single source but generates new text based on patterns in existing information, making traditional plagiarism checkers ineffective.
  • Professors Don’t Always Have Time to Analyze Writing Deeply – With large class sizes, most instructors focus on grading content rather than investigating writing patterns.
  • Students Can Edit AI Text – Some students tweak AI-generated essays to sound more natural, making detection even harder.

Despite these challenges, there are still key ways to identify AI-generated writing.

Signs That an Essay Might Be AI-Written

  1. Overly Generic and Vague Language

AI struggles with depth and nuance. Many AI-generated essays sound polished but lack specific insights. Instead of engaging analysis, they often contain generic statements like:

  • “Education is important for society.”
  • “Technology has changed the way people live.”
  • “There are many challenges students face in college.”

If an essay reads like a collection of broad statements without deep analysis or personal perspective, it might be AI-generated.

  1. Repetitive Sentence Structures

AI tends to repeat sentence patterns, especially when explaining complex ideas. You might notice:

  • Sentences starting the same way (e.g., “This means that…” or “This is because…”).
  • Repetitive phrasing with slight variations.
  • Overuse of transition words like “furthermore,” “moreover,” and “in addition.”

If a paragraph feels monotonous, it could be AI-generated.

  1. Unusual or Outdated References

AI often generates fake or outdated sources. If an essay includes:

  • Citations that don’t exist.
  • Studies that sound real but cannot be found online.
  • Sources from over a decade ago when newer research exists.

Then, it’s worth double-checking the legitimacy of those references.

  1. Lack of Personal Examples or Unique Insights

AI-generated essays often lack personal voice and experiences. Assignments like personal narratives, opinion pieces, and creative writing are harder for AI to replicate because they require individuality. If an essay avoids personal reflection or real-life examples when they would be relevant, that’s a red flag.

  1. Overuse of Complex Yet Unnecessary Words

AI sometimes tries too hard to sound smart. If an essay is full of unnecessarily long words or awkward phrasing, it might be AI-generated. Examples include:

  • “The utilization of advanced methodologies facilitates a comprehensive understanding of this concept.” (Instead of: “Using advanced methods helps us understand this idea.”)
  • “This discourse will expound upon the intricacies of societal transformation.” (Instead of: “This paper will explore how society changes.”)

If a student’s usual writing style is straightforward, but suddenly, an essay is packed with overly sophisticated vocabulary, it could indicate AI involvement.

Why Some Professors Still Struggle to Catch AI-Written Essays

Even with these red flags, AI-written essays can still slip through the cracks. Here’s why some professors have trouble detecting them:

  • Time Constraints – With dozens (or even hundreds) of essays to grade, professors don’t always have the time to scrutinize each one deeply.
  • Lack of Familiarity With AI Tools – Some educators aren’t familiar with how AI-generated content differs from human writing.
  • Well-Edited AI Text – If a student tweaks an AI-generated essay to add personality, remove awkward phrasing, and insert personal examples, it becomes much harder to detect.
  • Bias Toward Well-Written Work – Professors may assume that a well-structured, grammatically perfect essay is simply the work of a strong student rather than AI.

Conclusion

AI-written essays are becoming more sophisticated, making them harder to detect. However, by looking for vague language, repetitive structures, outdated references, and a lack of personal insight, professors and students alike can recognize AI-generated content.

For students, the takeaway is simple: while AI tools can be useful for brainstorming and structuring ideas, they shouldn’t replace authentic writing. Strong writing skills go beyond just getting good grades—they help in communication, critical thinking, and career success. Instead of relying on AI to do the work, use it as a tool to enhance your own abilities. After all, your unique voice and perspective are what truly make an essay stand out.

Flush the Fashion

Editor of Flush the Fashion and Flush Magazine. I love music, art, film, travel, food, tech and cars. Basically, everything this site is about.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.